Sartre, Marx and legal theory
Abstract
Bourgeois law, according to Marx, is ideological, but this familiar claim should not be taken to assert that law is merely an epiphenomenon of a specific material formation; there exists a dialectical relationship between our free praxis and the material conditions in which we act, within which dialectic legal systems and ideologies arise. While Marxist legal theorists have investigated the material causes of capitalist legal orders, they have not developed a fine-grained model that accounts for the (re)production of legal ideologies at the level of individual, free praxis. In this dissertation, I attempt to develop such a model, utilizing tools drawn from Jean-Paul Sartre's political theory. I first distinguish non-Marxist, analytical methodologies in legal theory from a Marxist dialectical methodology, arguing that certain non-Marxist theories of the "nature" of law, such as Thomistic natural law theory, classical Austinian positivism, and Savigny's historical theory, suffer from a common methodological failing, in that they treat a given theoretical or conceptual description of the law in abstraction from the historical context in which a theory is produced, and only in the context of which is that theory fully coherent. I then contrast these theories with Marx's dialectical-historical approach, arguing that Marx's theory is both descriptively and methodologically more adequate, particularly when supplemented by a phenomenology of bourgeois legal forms of human mediation. Here I draw on tools developed by Sartre in his Critique of Dialectical Reason, especially his theory of practical social ensembles. Law, in Sartre's theory, is a practical ensemble with the structure of an institution, and it is within this structure that the dialectic of praxis and material conditions which gives rise to bourgeois law becomes intelligible. I conclude with a discussion of the problem of rights as a primary form of human mediation, arguing for their transcendence through a form of mediation found paradigmatically in the gift.
Degree
Ph.D.
Advisors
McBride, Purdue University.
Subject Area
Philosophy|Law
Off-Campus Purdue Users:
To access this dissertation, please log in to our
proxy server.