The effect of peer review on information literacy outcomes in a chemical literature course
Abstract
This article describes the use of peer review in a writing project involving upper-level chemistry students in a chemical literature course, with the goal of improving student performance in meeting information literacy outcomes. Students were asked to find articles on a topic of their choice over the course of a semester and assemble the results into a brief paper, which was anonymously peer-reviewed by their classmates and then revised. The papers and the reviews were evaluated using a rubric based on ACRL information literacy competency standards for science, engineering, and technology students. Significant improvements relating to seven standards-based outcomes were observed (p< 0.02), corresponding to specific reviewer criticisms in up to 43% of student papers.
Keywords
Collaborative/Cooperative Learning, Communication/Writing, Constructivism, Curriculum, Undergraduate Research, Upper-Division Undergraduate
Date of this Version
12-3-2015
DOI
10.1021/acs.jchemed.5b00413
Recommended Citation
Zwicky, Dave and Hands, Michael D., "The effect of peer review on information literacy outcomes in a chemical literature course" (2015). Libraries Faculty and Staff Scholarship and Research. Paper 188.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1021/acs.jchemed.5b00413