Conference Year



Fault detection and diagnosis, FDD, gray-box model, air-conditioning


A methodology for evaluating the performance of fault detection and diagnostics (FDD) tools applied to unitary air conditioners has been developed by Yuill and Braun (2013). Data from faulted and unfaulted systems operating over a range of driving conditions are fed to the FDD tools, and the FDD responses are compared to the known operating conditions. The methodology originally relied upon experimental measurement data, but the amount of available data is limited, and evaluations can be far more meaningful if the operating conditions of the inputs can be controlled. Furthermore, a finite input set can be learned by an FDD algorithm, and the evaluation can be thereby gamed. To solve these problems, a large library of data from multiple systems under a wide range of conditions, with and without faults of varying magnitude, was generated with simulations from a novel gray-box modeling approach (Cheung and Braun 2013a, 2013b). The simulation outputs are used to train a neural network model, which is coupled to software that executes the evaluation method. The neural network model is much simpler than the semi-empirical approach, so it can produce evaluation inputs very quickly. This facilitates the evaluator generating semi-random conditions to provide a unique set of evaluation data that are sufficiently accurate and numerous to provide repeatable results. Some evaluation results from several FDD protocols are used to illustrate the success of this approach.

2605_presentation.pdf (724 kB)
Evaluation of Fault Detection and Diagnostics Tools by Simulation Results of Multiple Vapor Compression Systems